Showing posts with label climate science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate science. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Extremes

Last night I shivered in my summer PJ's as the cool summer in Melbourne continued under dreary grey skies, wind and a bit of rain.
Melbourne Experienced Wild Winds on Sunday 5th January 14
Meanwhile Queensland continued its run of extreme weather with a lightning storm following days of extreme heat. West Australia is also experiencing the hot weather, but those boom town folks are used to this!
Its been 4 years since my 1 kW Photovoltaic solar power unit was installed. Since then the number of units on roofs nearby has mushroomed, showing how my neighbours, mostly average Australians, have realized the benefits.
Unlike the current batch of reactionary, myopic, big-business oriented politicians!

In case you were still wondering how scientists managed to decide the globe is warming when its so chilly outside read these articles from the Conversation.

http://theconversation.com


Then go and read an actual book from your local library - one that discusses in more depth the pros and cons, theories, facts, knowns, known unknowns and unknown unknowns of science.
Somewhat more authoritative than the denialists and loud-mouthed opposition.

You never know what might happen if one looks past one's prejudices.
How do we get people to listen? More conversation about conservation!.




Friday, December 4, 2009

Scientists and skepticism

Recent news reports of the East Anglia Climate Research Unit scientists having vigorous debate and possible data manipulation regarding climate change should be news to no-one. Scientists are people and although they are working at the business end of the debate, collecting data and making experiments, many would also be part of the world of funding and politics. Thus to get the best research $$'s some fancy grant proposal writing is in order. Plus politicking to keep the research status high.
Other scientists take funding from organisations that are also interested in specific outcomes. Lamb producers fund research and surprise, surprise red meat is recommended as part of a healthy diet.
If a young scientist is employed (as PhD student, post doctoral or working scientist) in an organisation, their are often spoken & unspoken boundaries around which they do their research. Once the research is published, hedged with as many ifs, buts, perhaps, etc the referees then contribute to the wording of published papers.
With a climate science, the huge amount of data produced by experimentation is quite often only understandable once massaged through series of models and data manipulation. Secondary evidence such as tree ring analysis (dendrochronology) is based on assumptions about their rings and what they mean.
Thus it may be relatively easy for the same data to be interpreted in different ways by different scientists. So long as the data is published, repeated, vigorously discussed and continued, the scientist will work towards a moderate consensus. Until the next leap or major idea changing the interpretation.
The signal to noise ratio is open to interpretation also.
Politicians and the public need to also take leaps of policy based on incomplete data. The data is always incomplete because we are human and fallible. And often doing stuff before its too late is what we need to do.
The point about the climate data is that it will continue to grow in complexity and meaning. Exactly what policies we make based on the data is also complex, probably wrong and largely ineffectual.
Perhaps Tony Abbott, some economists and my son are right.
A carbon tax is what is needed!
Let the debate rage