Showing posts with label Federal Coalition Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Federal Coalition Government. Show all posts

Saturday, June 7, 2014

RET Review: Cat and Mouse Game




Can the following people give an unbiased review of the RET (Renewable Energy Target)?


  • Former Caltex head Dick Warburton, who has publicly questioned whether carbon emissions cause global warming. 
  • Economist Brian Fisher - previous work in oil and gas industry.
  • Shirley In't Veld, former head of WA's biggest coal generator.
  • Australian Energy Market Operator's Matt Zema

Now isn't that like putting a cat in the mouse house? 
What will you have after they've 'done the job'
Bare bones RET or nothing at all.
"For 14 years, the oil and gas industry has lobbied for the 20 per cent RET to be dumped."


Yet again shame on Tony Abbott and Greg Hunt, ministers of environmental destruction.


RenewEconomy's link to Solar Value Past Present and Future gives a good understanding of similar issues in the US.


http://www.ilsr.org/future-net-metering-distributed-solar/






Carbon Monoxide poisoning during the coal mine fire at Hazelwood this summer is the next whitewash. We shall see if the claims of the Fire Fighters Union stack up!

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Behaviour Change

As I was talking with my manager the other day about work related issues, I mentioned, the likely repeal of the Carbon Tax.
My manager, for whom I've always had a good relationship, immediately commented that taxing people was not a good way to change people's behaviour.
Now this surprised me, as public libraries survive on rates and local government regulations to provide the on-going funding for our services. In this case the population, as a whole, realize and approve of the taxation (rate). Public Libraries in Victoria have a very high approval rating and deliver services that can be measured as being worth more than their costs. The long term benefits of an informed and educated population have been effectively argued for a long time (see Thomas Jefferson quote), and are considered to be important in a democratic, open political system.

I have always felt the so-called Carbon Tax would be an effective mechanism in giving everyone the chance to rationally change their behaviour. Install more insulation and thus lower your power bills. Install solar panels and again lower your bills.
Not having a high electricity price does nothing to focus concern on this invisible substance called Carbon Dioxide. Giving handouts to polluters flies against the no-handout stance shown to struggling businesses like SPC, Holden etc.
Taxation & regulations however do not provide all the necessary levers to change behaviour. In an issue as complex as that of climate change, other mechanisms are absolutely necessary. We know the carrot can be more effective than the stick. Rebates encouraging insulation, solar panels and solar hot water spring to mind.
Their effectiveness has been demonstrated by the absolutely huge numbers of people taking up these offers.

Other mechanisms  include using social theory to encourage change and provide information. Mr Abbott's devastating use of simple messages has been hugely effective and us 'pro-climate' people need to replicate these simple, strong messages.
So a little research gave me this document. Changing Behaviour authored by the Australian Public Service.

Having a cost which is high enough to focus attention plus the tools and information to make a change, with leaders and communities is absolutely necessary.
Does repealing the Carbon Tax, dismantling the Clean Energy Financing mechanisms, stopping the RET and cutting off information on the real effects of climate change (Climate Council) sound like behaviour change? Reverse and perverse perhaps.
As the Public Service paper puts it
"A good example of a successful, comprehensive behavioural change strategy is Australia’s approach to tobacco control. There is a consensus in the Australian and international literature that a long-term and comprehensive approach to tobacco control is the most effective way of influencing the behaviour of smokers and potential smokers. Ad hoc, piecemeal action can have some impact but it is significantly more limited than a carefully planned, comprehensive, long-term approach encompassing education and information, legislation and restrictive measures and smoking cessation services. The comprehensive approach to tobacco control takes action in a range of areas using a range of policy tools. The effectiveness of the whole package is significantly greater than the sum of its parts."

So I'm off outside now to water my garden, parched with this excessive heat. Is this the heatwave we have to have or will that come again and again and again?

Tools of Change website (Canada)




Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Federal Parliament Resumes: The Calm before the Storm perhaps?

Like many 'normal' people I've been astounded by the lack of media surrounding the various decisions and policy directions of the new Abbott Coalition Government.
Any utterance from the previous government, not an official Coalition but an uneasy alliance of groups, was met from many influential media commentators with a form of viciousness and hysteria that effectively blocked any conversation on what was actually happening.
The current calm, honeymoon period would seem welcome except that I suspect the very media restraint has more to do with control than anything real.

My acquaintance with the 48 Laws of Power indicates Law 4: Always say less than necessary is being followed scrupulously by both Coalition politicians and their media colleagues. Thus we hear very little happening about the "Stop the Boats" promise. News is seemingly coming through, supposedly from Indonesian sources, of boats being stopped at sea, being 'sent' back to Indonesia and having this action refused by the sovereign Indonesian Government. The boats are then taken to Christmas Island.
End result - the policies are not working!
So although the Boat numbers have slowed, before and after the elections, due to the government policy of off-shoring the migration, the boats have not stopped. But our daily 'information' has.
"Knowledge is power" said Sir Francis Bacon (or the latin translation)
Lack of media criticism is worrying but lack of media hysteria is not.

Today Tony Windsor, ex Interdependent MP from New England, gave a thoughtful answer to why the Carbon Tax should not be repealed (ABC Radio 774) . As a farmer of many years and politician as well, I have always been impressed at how he actually answers the questions, not with personal attacks, OTT hysteria and a rising voice of anger, but a considered statement of his views, experience and indication of actual knowledge. He will be missed.

So the first action of Tony Abbott's Government will be the repeal of the Carbon Tax. I urge all the opposition parties in both Houses and particularly the Senate, to hold firm. Don't abolish the Carbon Tax. The people are not always right particularly if fed misinformation, business is not always right and the environment is needing a helping hand. We must pay for our pollution and we must allow policies that affirm the right of the environment ahead of almost anything else.
Can you imagine Typhoon Hiyan hitting Brisbane or Sydney?? What cost for a few $$ per day to us all, including business?